This kinda happened to me once, but with Netflix and their DVD by mail stuff. I had flat out lost the DVD and I think I just said it got lost in the mail or something like that and they were like “Oh. That’s ok! We still enjoy taking your money ever month!”
That copy of The Proposal has still not turned up. It is likely living with my college housemate’s copy of The 40 Year Old Virgin, which also mysteriously disappeared years ago.
I wonder if those DVDs have kids now. I wonder what the kids of those two movies would be…